Monday, September 10, 2007

A Picture is Worth a Thousand Words

I decided to look and see how "Little Red" is portrayed in pictures in children's books. I always had the depiction in my own head of a girl around six or seven with a bright red cape and blonde hair. She was always very innocent and naive.
The first four pictures I have included (#1, #2, #3, #4) all came from children's books and were what I expected. There were sweet looking girls in blue dresses and red capes with their hoods up. None of the girls appeared to be from this time period, they all looked like they were from the past with their modest dress and aprons. These girls seems to be the standard girl portrayed to children in picture books.
My ideas on why the girl is portrayed as young is that children of the age of this girl are able to identify with her. Despite the time difference the girl seems to be just like a normal 6, 7 or eight year old. This day in age children of the age of this girl could identify with the idea of "Never talk to strangers". This phrase is drilled into the heads of children in our society. I do not think the illustrators meant to portray any messages of puberty or sex. If they had I believe the girl would have been shown in a different light. Even in picture five (#5) the wolf is shown as a definite threat, but not as a sexual predator. Little Red is so young that the threat doesn't seem like it could possibly be related to sexuality.
These ideas can contribute to our discussion of Little Red Riding Hood because we must look at the reader's response to a story to obtain a current meaning of that story. The reader's response though, is greatly influenced by the way the character is portrayed. The reader has to make assumptions based on what they are given from the author (storyteller), illustrator, and his or her own life experiences.
It is difficult to tell if the illustrators grew up on the same portrayal of this character or if their own life experiences influenced their depiction of her. Did the illustrator draw a young girl because in his mind he saw her as six or because that is the age she tend to be portrayed? Did both things have an influence on the outcome of the picture?

Jigsaw's Little Red Riding Hood

What I researched and why:
When I started this I really wanted to find an example of how we have turned the Red Riding Hood story into a "sexy" image. Red is often portrayed as a sort of temptress, walking through the woods and luring the wolves to come and get her if they dare. The concept of Red intentionally calling the wolves out was interesting to me. I was looking for TV commercials with this image other than the ones mentioned in the last half of the Orenstein book. After I came across the clip I chose to put up, I switched my focus more to the woodcutter's role in the story because it seemed like a valid course to switch to. Usually, the woodcutter's interest in Red is not at all sexual, but rather very paternal. He rescues her from the wolf and makes her safe again. In this version of the story, the opposite is true. Without the woodcutter's intervention, we can assume that Red never would have even come across the wolf, let alone need his protection.

What I found:
I found a variety of adds that use this temptress image of Little Red Riding Hood, including a Chanel 5 and a Pepsi commercial, but accidentally stumbled across this video. It comes from the Saw II DVD, but no worries it's actually a shadow puppet show so there's no gore or anything like that. Here is the link to the video: http://http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eIB1R-pGVD0

My interpretation:
In this version, the woodcutter is in love with Red, a self-assured and strong woman who relies on no one but herself. The woodcutter is a stalker; a man obsessed with Red and determined to have her despite her repeated refusal to accept his advances. He is no longer the paternal savior at the end of the story, but now is the engineer of her downfall. This story actually has two wolves, the wild animal that desires Red solely for the purpose of devouring her, and the human who desires Red in a very different and much more twisted way. The wolf only wants to eat her, but the woodcutter intends to keep her even after death and continue using her as he pleases once she is completely under his control. It is implied at the beginning that the woodcutter loves and wants to protect Red, but in truth, he is perhaps even more evil than the wolf. Red, surprisingly is not at fault in this particular version. Usually she stops to talk to the wolf, but here she never even speaks to the wolf. Even when talking with the woodcutter, she only speaks once when she tells him that she's not interested. She doesn't stray from the path and she doesn't talk to strangers. Despite the way that her image is represented (very curvaceous), Red is essentially a complete innocent in this story, and still she is taken advantage of, not by an outside, wild threat, but rather by a man who is always near her and would be expected to protect her.

What this adds to our discussion:
So far in class, we have mainly discussed the woodcutter as being the positive male role who comes in at the end to save Red from her folly and to set the world right again. He comes in at the end, after the story has been told and only by good luck is he close enough to even notice that anything is wrong. The woodcutter in this story is present from the beginning, but instead of being a protective role, he instead is a very dangerous character. His presence in the story completely changes the way that the story ends and what the moral of the story is, if we can really call the ending a moral.

The PC Little Red Riding Hood

What I researched and why: My favorite thing about reading the different versions (and interpretations) of “Little Red Riding Hood” was seeing how each version both emphasized and left out certain things, namely what the particular teller thought should be emphasized, and what he/she thought should be left out. What is strengthened and cut out of each version lets us know what was important to the teller, the author, or the times in which they lived, what they thought to be good and what they thought to be bad. It also shows us that notions of “goodness” and “badness” change, as all of the versions have different ideas about morality. I wanted to find a modern version that didn’t deviate in an outrageous way from the original storyline, but that presented yet another different idea about what is good and what is bad.

What I found: A writer named James Finn Garner wrote a book called Politically Correct Bedtime Stories: Modern tales for our life and times which contains a politically correct version of Little Red Riding Hood.

My interpretation: I thought that this story was incredibly clever and funny. I know that it is meant to be taken as a joke, but just like the other versions of the story that we have read, this version has its own particular idea about what is good and what is not. It has its own morality, namely, political correctness to the extreme. In this version, Little Red Riding Hood is not the “prettiest” girl in the village (as she is in Perrault’s version), nor is she “sweet” (as she is in the Grimms’s tale), she is merely a “young person” who is not at all innocent, but rather “confident…in her own budding sexuality” (she is so well-informed that she is familiar with “Freudian imagery”). The wolf is not evil but rather an “outcast” with a “unique worldview.” The grandmother is not old and weak but “mature” and “fully capable.” And it is the “woodchopper-person”—the one who is usually the ideal savior, the “most attractive figure…because he rescues the good and punishes the bad” (Bettelheim 177)— who is violently dispatched at the end, which fits into the particular morality of this story. The “woodchopper-person,” after all, represents the patronizing and all-powerful patriarchal figure, an ideal that is passé and offensive to some people, and therefore not politically correct, and therefore, according to this story, not good.

What I think this adds to our discussion: We discussed New Historicism in class on Thursday, and I think that this story, which exhibits our current culture’s concern with political correctness, emphasizes a need to study tales in light of their particular contexts, to trace how morals in stories have changed according to the times in which they were written. Just as we learned that Perrault’s story emphasizes the virtues of the French court culture (the unchaste girl is eaten up), and the Grimms’s tale emphasizes the 19th century virtue of obedience in children (the little girl disobeys, is eaten, is saved, and vows never to disobey mother again), this modern story emphasizes certain virtues that exist in our present time, like political correctness. Today, very generally speaking, progressiveness and open-mindedness are viewed as good, while things that are backward or rigidly traditional are viewed as bad. This is why when Little Red, her grandmother, and the wolf set up “an alternative household based on mutual respect” while the man who “assumes” he needs to save the day is vanquished is, according to the morals of this story, a good, happy ending. Even though what is bad is different in these different versions of the tale, what the versions have in common is the violence with which the “badness” is dealt with—these stories seem to teach us that “badness,” no matter what it is, needs to be done away with completely, needs to be devoured, killed. But with the extent to which historical perspectives show us how much ideas of “goodness” and “badness” change over time, it is just interesting to think about why these three stories, separated by centuries and vastly different ideals, all felt the need to represent the triumph over evil by stamping out the “evil” so violently and completely.

Thursday, September 6, 2007

Some Additional Background

Great posts so far!! (Remember everyone that part of your grade comes from responding to other students on the blog via the "comments" button, so let our first posters know what you think of their findings.)

I wanted to also post an article from The Journal of Mythic Arts as optional reading. It provides an alternate ending to The Grandmother's Tale, additional historical context, and some useful lists of modern adaptations and criticism.

Wednesday, September 5, 2007

Into the Woods

What I Researched, and What I Found: I researched the musical Into the Woods because I have heard the music before, and I was curious to see how the lyrics compared to the versions we read in class. I feel that the visual portrayal of the interaction between Little Red Riding Hood and the Wolf is very interesting, and somewhat different from the versions we were exposed to. There are two songs dealing specifically with Little Red Riding Hood and the Wolf. The first song is called Hello Little Girl, which is a dialog between Little Red Riding Hood and the Wolf. The second number is I Know Things Now, which is sung by Little Red Riding Hood after she is saved by the woodsman. I have posted the links to the lyrics, and have also posted video clips of the musical numbers. (Just to warn everyone, the Wolf's costume in the best clip I could find is a little...revealing, but symbolic.)
Hello Little Girl: Video

I know Things Now: Video

How I Interpret It: In this version, the Wolf's intentions are plainly stated. The versions we read in Orenstein's book all portray the wolf as evil and provocative, but only in the Grimm's' version did the wolf verbalize his true intentions. The wolf is obviously presented as the villain, and Red Riding Hood as the naive victim of seduction. The wolf expresses his incredible, lusty desire to make the "soft and supple" Red Riding Hood his snack, in a sort of sexual way. By reading the lyrics, this symbolism may not be as apparent as it is in the video. The wolf is wearing a tight jacket, showing his muscular physique, and though Red Riding Hood tries to stick to the path her mother ordered her to follow, her curiosity, intrigue, and lust cause her to stray. After Red Riding Hood is eaten by the wolf, and then saved by the woodsman, she sings I Know Things Now in response to her experience. I think it's very interesting that she was grateful to be alive, but also regretted the fact that she involuntarily gained so much knowledge from her experience. She seems to waver a lot in her reasoning. Statements such as,
"I should have heeded her advice...but he seemed so nice," "He made me feel excited-well, excited and scared," and "Isn't it nice to know a lot! But sometimes not," imply that Red Riding Hood may have matured too early. She wishes that she had not been forced to grow up so quickly, and that she still had the privilege of being naive, as she was before. In this aspect, this version ties in very well with the "coming of age" theme we discussed in class.

What I Think it Adds to Discussion: All of the stories we have read so far have morals; some more obvious than others. I think that this is an interesting take on the story, in that Red Riding Hood expresses her understanding of the moral, and promises that she will not stray from the path again, but it seems as though she still has reservations. She doesn't seem completely content with her ending, and I think she may have enjoyed a more positive encounter with the wolf. This reveals that Little Red Riding Hood may not be as innocent as she seems. I would like to compare this version to the other versions we read, and see if any of the other stories imply that the Little Red Riding Hood character may not be so innocent either. It would be interesting for the class to discuss their take on this version, and to see if they view the symbolism as I do. I would especially like to hear everyone's take on the last two lines of I Know Things Now.

Tuesday, September 4, 2007

The Woodsman's First Tale

What I researched and Why/What I found: I looked up a version of Little Red Riding Hood I had heard in an audio book because I thought it put a very unique and sinister twist on the story. While the original versions of this tale involved everything from cannibalism to self deification to possible implications of sex with children, I think this version gives it a very different, and perhaps even more sinister for its subtlety, tint to the tale. I've tried twice now to get the file on the site, but I can't seem to figure it out. I'll be bringing my mp3 player and little speakers to class as well as the CD in case we can play it in the class computer. The rest of this might not make so much sense until you hear the story.
The story is part of the novel The Book of Lost Things by John Connolly. If you are interested in new and disturbing, and often hilariously so, twists on old stories, then I highly recommend this novel: it is one of my favorites. The story refers to creatures called the Lou (I'm not sure if I spelled that correctly since I've only ever listened to this book) and in particular a male named La Roy. These creatures are some of the most sinister in the novel.

My interpretation: I think this version casts the girl as the villain in a superb way. The chase and subsequent seduction reflects the temptation of the original tales, yet in reverse: she has literally gone searching for her demise. Perhaps my favorite part of this story is later when she calls other girls to her in the forest. This continues the reversal, with the wolf being inactive, even docile, and a near non-participant. With the Lou acting as villains in the novel, with their main flaw and defining 'evil' feature being unending hunger and greed, the question comes up several times whether this feature comes from the Lou's wolf heritage, or their human heritage, asking us to look within ourselves for the hunger/greed of the beast. I think this question is at the core of both the original versions and this revised version and that the reversal of positions Connolly presents brings that question of humanity to the surface of the story.

What I think it adds to our discussion: One thing I think this story can really contribute, especially so early in the semester, is to help dispel the idea of children's stories as 'innocent.' This story is very dark, with no happily ever after, and the result of the story is the creation of the most foul creatures in the novel. I also think on a purely literary note that the efficiency of language in this piece is, well, top notch. I also think it would be interesting to look at the affective influence of this piece on its readers: how does an audience respond to a story, one that is seemingly sacred in our social script, being torn apart before their eyes?

A Not So Evil Wolf

What I researched and why: My choice to look deeper into the world of Little Red Ridding Hood comes not so much from an interest in the tale itself but rather a curiosity about the extent to which this story has been told, retold, and told yet again. Before this class, I was unaware of the massive following and intrigue a tale such as Little Red Ridding Hood could and does possess, and so my interest was sparked to see what I could find to broaden my understanding and that of the class with respect to the phenomenon that is Little Red Ridding Hood.

What I found:
In searching the Internet the best way I know how (google), I entered the key words "little red ridding hood modern day," and after a page or so of searching I came across what I found to be a different and interesting interpretation or reflection on Little Red Ridding Hood. The poem entitled, "The Wolf's Postscript to 'Little Red Ridding Hood'," can be found at this link and was written by a Kashmiri exiled poet named Agha Shahid Ali. He lived in the US and was a member of the Academy of American Poets. Along with teaching at many esteemed universities, he published many works of poetry before his death in 2001 (more on Ali can be found at by surfing around the site at which the poem can be found).

My interpretation:
Ali, while not going so far as to say that the wolf is "good," does make the reader see a different side to the wolf and the entire story of Little Red Ridding Hood. Firstly, in reading a classic version of the tale, the character of the wolf is considered to be an evil and manipulative character, yet this poem paints him as more compassionate while still admitting his evil deeds. Ali also points out some common sense discrepancies in the story which one does not consider because of the presupposed notion of an evil wolf (not having eaten the grandmother in the past). The issue of molestation which he brings up can, in my eyes, be disputed based on which version of the story is being read, but to discredit this poem for not taking into account Red's original nakedness would be a mistake. Finally the wolf pleads for sympathy by pointing out that it was completely unnecessary to fill his bowels with rocks, as it is in the Grimm's version, because he would surely die anyways after being cut open. Upon finishing the reading of this poem, I found myself sympathetic to some of the wolf's claims and found his arguments well structured and logical. In this sense, the wolf, to me, is less of a savage evildoer and more of a semi-compassionate and reasonable teacher.

What I think it adds to our discussion: During Tuesday's class, the discussion towards the end of class turned to the deconstructionists approach to literature. In this discussion it was said that "all words have meaning only in relation to opposites." This concept implies that the nature of the duality of themes requires that opposing concepts overlap at least to the point of making the other relevant. I think that this poem is a great example of just that. While the wolf does not leave the poem completely redeemed of his sins, he does walk away with some dignity restored, and the heroine, Little Red Ridding Hood, can be seen as a bit cruel in the fact that she helped to stuff the wolf with rocks and garbage. In this way, the apparent "good one" in the story shares a small amount of evil with which to contrast the massive evil done by the "bad one". At the same time, the "bad one" salvages enough goodness to exemplify the shining innocence that Little Red Ridding Hood so clearly possesses.

P.S. Thank you for taking the time to read this, I hope you enjoyed the poem. I look forward to your comments.