Monday, September 17, 2007

The History of Little King Pippin

What I researched and why/What I found: Well for starters, I wanted to find a clearer version of The History of Little King Pippin before I started blogging about it. For all of you with bad eyes like me, this site helped me get through the story without wondering what every 5th word was. http://www.openlibrary.org/details/historyoflittlek00bewiiala Then I moved on to try to find more information about the story. Sadly, it doesn't really seem to be that popular of a piece. Every article I found merely had a brief mention of the title in it, without a whole lot of information.

My interpretation: Fortunately, what this story does have are very interesting parallels between this story and "The Dialogue Between Christ, a Youth, and the Devil." There were varying dates which the story was reportedly published, however, from my best estimation the original was published somewhere around 1786. While "The Dialogue" was somewhere around 1777...making them not too far apart in terms of the time in which they were published. However, where the two stories are different is in the idea that a sinner may be saved. For example, the story states,

"But oh, shame to tell, not one of them, except harry Harmless himself, could
repeat, or indeed had ever learned a singly prayer; upon which, Harry, justly
concluding, that those naughty boys who had so totally neglected their duty to
their Creator, could have no claim whatever to his protection, thought he should
be in more safety alone that in such wicked company, therefore moved to a
distance from them, and kneeled down to prayer himself; and he had not left hem
but a few minutes before two monstrous lions came and devoured every one of
them: after they had eaten these wicked boys, they went up to Harry Harmless but
instead of devouring him, as they had the others, they seemed as fond of him as
a dam of her young, licked his face and hands with their tongues, and then lay
down quietly upon the ground by his side; for God Almighty had heard his
prayers, as he always will those of all good little boys and girls, and had
converted the natural rage and fierceness of these dreadful bests into the
meekness and gentleness of lambs" (21).


Here, we see a "bad" child, (though he was not wicked in the sense that the other boys were wicked) being saved as a result of begging God's forgiveness. Whereas, in "The Dialogue" when the youth begs Gods forgiveness, Christ turns away and offers him to Death. Additionally, we see a purely "Good" character in Little King Pippin, (as is made abundantly clear through the repetition) who never falters. Let me just say, that if I was a child in this era, I would be pretty frightened. One either must be perfect and good, or wretchedly bad and going to hell. The characters offer little room for interpretation otherwise. Only Harry Harmless is saved even though he has a fault, however, his only fault was that he was associated with the "wicked" boys. The only thing that saved him was that he repented and remembered his prayers.

What this has to contribute to our discussion: The idea of the perfect child with absolutely no room for interpretation also reminded me of the Harry Potter post. Little King Pippin is the literal representation of what the author of that post wants Harry Potter to be...perfect, with absolutely no room for flaws. Good is always good, and bad is always bad (unless it's not THAT bad, in which case it can repent and become completely good, without ever making a mistake again). In my opinion, there is nothing to learn from a story like that...characters have flaws, just as people do...and we learn from their flaws just as we learn from our own. As Bettleheim mentioned, stories with blatant morals (such as Perrault's LRRH) don't offer as much for children to learn as stories which can be interpreted. This is because as the children grow up, so do their interpretations of stories. I'm quite certain my 13 year old sister doesn't read Harry Potter and take the same things from it that I do...but the important thing is that we can both read it, AND take something from it. The main thing I would take from Little King Pippin if I had read it in it's original time period, would be to be very afraid of making mistakes.

Friday, September 14, 2007

Harry Haters

Hi all,

I wanted to post the 10 Things to Hate About Harry Potter list that I mentioned in class. It is very interesting how arguments about children's literature tend to repeat themselves throughout history. Censorship/banned books debates in general tend to use the child as their "test case"--interestingly, given that not all of the books that are banned are actually meant for children in the first place.

In any case, the point that I was trying to make in class about evaluation is that the work we're doing in our class--that is, interpreting children's literature--is at the heart of these discussions about appropriateness for children. After all, one must decide what a text means, where it comes from, and what effect it is likely to have on children in order to come to a conclusion about what books are "good" or "bad." Being aware of the arguments that get made in the name of children's welfare helps us begin to situate ourselves critically vis a vis the texts we are reading.

BTW, you are allowed to comment on my posts, as well as those of your classmates, for credit. I'd love to hear what you think about the anti-Harry phenomenon.

Thursday, September 13, 2007

The New England Primer



What I researched and why:
After reading Anna Mae Duane’s article “Casualties of the Rod,” I was interested in learning about the types of literature and leisure that Puritan children would be permitted to engage in. The first thing I learned was that leisure was not permitted. I imagined that there might at least be some kind of Biblical game or activity, but was unable to find evidence of any such thing. As far as literature goes, it is obvious that the Bible would be the “NY Times Bestseller” of the day, even for children. I thought that this couldn’t possibly be the only book that they would read. This assumption was correct, though not entirely. The Bible influenced every aspect of Puritan life, including what I assume was the second source of written word accessed by children: textbooks.

What I found
: After several searches involving the words “Puritan”, “children”, “stories”, and “literature,” I realized that each search led me to the same work, titled The New England Primer. It was originally written by Benjamin Larkin around 1700. The exact date of publication was not something I could easily find, as the primer was published in London before it was published in Boston. There are many editions of the primer. A partial facsimile of The New England Primer (created in 1901) can be found here. The facsimile does not illustrate the entire contents of the primer (which includes the famed alphabet, verses, catechism questions, and the poem A Dialogue Between Christ, Youth, and the Devil). A typed version of the contents of the primer from 1777 can be found here.

My interpretation: One of the aspects of Duane’s article that struck me the most was her discussion of Mather and his views on children and God. She writes, “According to Mather, God inflicts an astonishing variety of retributions upon the body of an insubordinate child” (71). She goes on to discuss a sermon in which Mather illustrated this point through the use of Proverbs 30:17. To be a child in the time period when you might hear things like this frightened me. I know that around the same time, the philosopher John Locke had suggested the idea of tabula rasa – that children were born into this world as “blank slates” waiting to be written on. It makes sense, then, that the Puritans would fear for the goodness of their children and surround them with cautionary Bible tales, as well as to guard them from what they felt was the wild abandon and sinfulness of the American Indians. But the poem A Dialogue between Christ, Youth and the Devil portrays such a hopeless situation: It is easier to follow the way of the Devil, but his way leads to pain and suffering; furthermore, following the way of Christ is difficult and most likely will lead to the same end. Surely, I thought, the entire childhood of a Puritan was not filled with such hopelessness and fear. Again, I was wrong - as is evidenced by the contents of the primer.

What I think this adds to our discussion: The Duane article and A Dialogue Between Christ, Youth, and the Devil alone paint us what I felt was an abstract picture of Puritan childhood. I feel that – especially for those students who are interested in the historical aspects of literature – The New England Primer offers a little bit of insight into the life of a Puritan child. Though it may be a life of fear, it is important to understand that children’s literature written during this time can most likely be read with the understanding that it was intended to keep Puritan children as sinless as possible.
Research and Why: Before this class I had never read or heard of “A Dialogue Between Christ, Youth, and the Devil.” I thought the title in itself sounded very interesting and figured it would be a good way to learn more about it by picking it as one of my blog entries. It certainly opened my eyes to how intense the New England Primer 1777 edition was, and in several ways I was amazed as to what was portrayed to young children as being sinful, wrong, or evil. The Devil’s response to the child talking about finding pleasure in playing and singing, is happiness. The Devil is glad because those things were portrayed as negative activities during this time. Some places in the writing made me laugh, while others were extremely frustrating. After our discussions in class I found using historical, political, psychological, and textual analysis was extremely helpful and interesting.

What I found: Unfortunately I could not find a lot of information on this piece, all of it’s connections were tied to the New England Primer (I included a picture of the book below if you are interested in what it looked like) where it was initially published. (http://www.sacred-texts.com/chr/nep/1777/index.htm) This is a link to the website I looked at of the edition in which “A Dialogue Between Christ, Youth, and the Devil” was published initially. I think the additional material in the book gives a lot of information about the text we are looking at. This includes "An Alphabet of Lessons for Youth.", "Spiritual Milk for American BABES.", and "Some proper Names of MEN and WOMEN, to teach Children to spell their own."
My interpretation: “A Dialogue Between Christ, Youth, and the Devil” in my opinion was a result of the Puritan culture during the time frame it was written in. Education and religion went hand in hand as the alphabet, spelling, and English in general were taught to the youth. The fear entwined in the majority of this book was an attempt to create “good” and “moral” children. The two ways I thought were most helpful to analyze in this instance were psychologically and historically. There were obvious psychological messages that this text was trying to give the children who were being raised with this as one of their main educational texts. With lines from the Devil to the Youth like, "If thou wilt but be ruled by me, an artist thou shalt quickly be..." there pictures of the author's preconceived ideas about artist's and what type of person they were thought to be. The connections between playing, singing, art, and nature and death leading to eternal damnation were everywhere. How scary for a child! How scary for an adult! I found the ending to be the most interesting as Death joined the dialogue stating, "Youth, I am come to take thy breath, and carry thee to shades of death: No pity to thee I can show, thou hast thy God offended so." This clearly shows the cultural history of this time-frame. God was not a loving being, but a condemning being and one who should be feared.

How this relates to what we've been discussing in class: Over the past three weeks we have discussed the four main ways it is beneficial to analyze children's literature. These being textual, historical, political, and psychological. Although I could find ways in which each of these could be used as tools to discover more about "A Dialogue Between Christ, Youth, and the Devil" I found historical and psychological to be particularly helpful. Just as the authors for "Little Red Riding Hood" wrote their versions of the story differently depending on the time which it was written and the cultural ideas and morals held in that time, the text I focused on was written similarly. This applies and can be used to further our class discussions, it is actually a very strong piece because a lot of the psychological aspects are so strong. There is no beating around the bush with this piece of literature and the points it is trying to make.

Wednesday, September 12, 2007

a "forgotten" story

I set out looking for other interpretations of the dialogue between children, the devil, and Christ. I found an interesting web page, which addresses how children's books have changed from dealing exclusively with Biblical matters to sometimes nonsense. What initially interested me was the first illustration shown, "The Devil and the Disobedient Child."
I researched this relationship because I find the relationship between children and religion especially interesting. The Bible puts such a fear of the Devil into children's hearts, and many fairy tales aim to further this fear. Children are taught that the devil is present in almost all situations and to always be alert. I found the reading especially interesting because the child engages in conversation with the devil, which could be construed as a sin within itself.
I would like to contrast this to the reading for today. Although there are no illustrations in the reading, it seems that the child knows with whom he is talking to. Both the devil and Christ seem to be forthcoming with their identities. In the illustration that I found, the devil seems to be a shadowed figure who perhaps could assume any form. Also, I think it is of note that the disobedient child is a female, which we'll cover more in depth as the semester continues.
I also found it interesting that "The Devil and the Disobedient Child" is considered a forgotten book of the American Nursery. Although the plot may be lost, the general lesson is very much remembered and present in current children's literature. It can easily be seen in Little Red Riding Hood, as we discussed in class.
I think it is also important to discuss the fact that in children's literature the devil is often portrayed as a man. This could be related to the fact that early children's literature was based in biblical texts, and the Bible refers to the devil as a male figure. I could also see the devil as a male, especially in Little Red Riding Hood, when looking at Perrault's version as a cautionary tale perhaps related to male pedophiles.
I think when reading a text, it can prove insightful to look at different illustrations that relate to the text. This can help visual learners and can also showcase different interpretations of a relationship, as shown in this case.
I was trying to figure out which interpretation strategy religion would fit into, and perhaps it could be rooted in political criticism. And perhaps even further distilled into Christian Criticism. This also led me to look at the other reading in relation to the dialogue between Christ, the child, and the devil. In the "Casualties of the Rod" reading, children's bodies are viewed as places where God's disappointment materializes. Does this mean that children are closer to God/Christ than adults are?

Tuesday, September 11, 2007

Another Illustration

Thanks, Molly, for looking at Little Red illustrations!

Here's another one from an 1867 Perrault edition. It's probably the most famous older illustration, and it's the one that Bettelheim talks about on page 176 of his essay. This one is frequently read as sexual, but you may have differing interpretations. I thought I'd add it to the mix!

Interviews with Jack Zipes

Hi all,

I'm loving all of the blog activity! I didn't get the Jack Zipes article to you in time to read for today, but I will be sending it as optional reading in case you are interested in feminist/political approaches to Little Red. I was initially interested in pairing Zipes with Bettelheim because Zipes has been one of the most outspoken critics to disagree with Bettelheim's famous reading of Little Red Riding Hood. Yet, they actually have some things in common, including their distaste with a lot of present-day children's culture.

In any case, I thought I'd post links to two really interesting interviews with Zipes (not required reading, but fascinating stuff!). He has quite a bit to say about the historical, political, and even psychological uses of fairy tales. One appears on the website of an independent horror fiction press. The other on a website that deals with children's cinema. Thus, they present interesting perspectives about genres that we have not considered in class thus far.