My interpretation: Fortunately, what this story does have are very interesting parallels between this story and "The Dialogue Between Christ, a Youth, and the Devil." There were varying dates which the story was reportedly published, however, from my best estimation the original was published somewhere around 1786. While "The Dialogue" was somewhere around 1777...making them not too far apart in terms of the time in which they were published. However, where the two stories are different is in the idea that a sinner may be saved. For example, the story states,
"But oh, shame to tell, not one of them, except harry Harmless himself, could
repeat, or indeed had ever learned a singly prayer; upon which, Harry, justly
concluding, that those naughty boys who had so totally neglected their duty to
their Creator, could have no claim whatever to his protection, thought he should
be in more safety alone that in such wicked company, therefore moved to a
distance from them, and kneeled down to prayer himself; and he had not left hem
but a few minutes before two monstrous lions came and devoured every one of
them: after they had eaten these wicked boys, they went up to Harry Harmless but
instead of devouring him, as they had the others, they seemed as fond of him as
a dam of her young, licked his face and hands with their tongues, and then lay
down quietly upon the ground by his side; for God Almighty had heard his
prayers, as he always will those of all good little boys and girls, and had
converted the natural rage and fierceness of these dreadful bests into the
meekness and gentleness of lambs" (21).
Here, we see a "bad" child, (though he was not wicked in the sense that the other boys were wicked) being saved as a result of begging God's forgiveness. Whereas, in "The Dialogue" when the youth begs Gods forgiveness, Christ turns away and offers him to Death. Additionally, we see a purely "Good" character in Little King Pippin, (as is made abundantly clear through the repetition) who never falters. Let me just say, that if I was a child in this era, I would be pretty frightened. One either must be perfect and good, or wretchedly bad and going to hell. The characters offer little room for interpretation otherwise. Only Harry Harmless is saved even though he has a fault, however, his only fault was that he was associated with the "wicked" boys. The only thing that saved him was that he repented and remembered his prayers.
What this has to contribute to our discussion: The idea of the perfect child with absolutely no room for interpretation also reminded me of the Harry Potter post. Little King Pippin is the literal representation of what the author of that post wants Harry Potter to be...perfect, with absolutely no room for flaws. Good is always good, and bad is always bad (unless it's not THAT bad, in which case it can repent and become completely good, without ever making a mistake again). In my opinion, there is nothing to learn from a story like that...characters have flaws, just as people do...and we learn from their flaws just as we learn from our own. As Bettleheim mentioned, stories with blatant morals (such as Perrault's LRRH) don't offer as much for children to learn as stories which can be interpreted. This is because as the children grow up, so do their interpretations of stories. I'm quite certain my 13 year old sister doesn't read Harry Potter and take the same things from it that I do...but the important thing is that we can both read it, AND take something from it. The main thing I would take from Little King Pippin if I had read it in it's original time period, would be to be very afraid of making mistakes.
