Thursday, September 27, 2007

Little Lord Fauntleroy and Boyhood







Since we're talking more about boyhood today, I thought I would post the images that I mentioned last class--of boys being dressed as children's book character, Little Lord Fauntleroy. Fauntleroy is portrayed as masculine throughout Burnett's text, but, as you can see, the image associated with him is rather feminized, very different from our Tom Sawyer.

Fauntleoy is also generally understood as an apologist for certain 19c social values, including charity, civilized behavior, and democratic justice. It might be useful to think about how Twain interacts with both this other dominant portrayal of boyhood and with these social values. If his boyhood is not about civilized manners, what kinds of things does he want boyhood to be or represent?

Romantic Child

What I researched and why: I wanted to post on Tom Sawyer because I remember very fondly being read/reading this story many times when I was a child . When looking back on it I think I really got a kick out of hearing about when Tom would be so close to getting caught, but somehow managing to escape. I think I also enjoyed the friendship that Tom and Huck shared, and the knack for mischief that they shared. So when I began to look for related material on Tom Sawyer and found that there was not a lot there, I immediately started to look for things about Tom and Huck.

What I found: After searching around a little bit I came across a web site that has letters sent between Mark Twain and a librarian at Brooklyn College: http://www.twainquotes.com/19351102.html I think this is an article from the New York Times in 1935. This article is talking about how the head librarian at this particular college disagreed with his colleague that was trying to get the characters of Tom and Huck banned from the children’s department. To show his concern he sent a letter to Twain to tell him what they did and why. Twain’s response is hilarious, absolutely dripping with sarcasm. After his letter they were removed from the children’s department but put on shelves accessible to children and adults. Also at the end of the article it cites Twain talking about how the people in Concord, Massachusetts despised Huck because he lied and swore.

My interpretation and how this relates to our discussion in class: I found this article particularly interesting because it shows the nineteenth century view of the romantic child. This is made clear when they claim that Tom and Huck were “bad examples for ingenuous youth.” At first I was not sure what ingenuous meant, after looking it up I found out it means innocent; and just last class we were discussing the view of the romantic child being pure and innocent. The people at the Brooklyn Library were concerned that Tom and Huck would spoil the innocent minds of the children, and turn them into bad little boys and girls because they claimed these characters were coarse, deceitful and mischievous.
I also found the letter that he wrote to the professor to be really funny. Although in the preface of Tom Sawyer he states that the book is “intended mainly for the entertainment of boys and girls” in the letter to the professor he claims that he wrote the books for adults only. He relays across the message of the romantic child saying, “The mind that becomes soiled in youth can never again be washed clean.” Although he used heavy sarcasm here just to get some people worked up I assume; these are exactly the ideas of childhood in the nineteenth century. People believed that children were born with the mark of God, and they did not want them to be tainted; and this idea was very different from the earlier views of children. It is easy to see that Mark Twain does not agree with that view, and only wrote the book to entertain children and maybe even some adults.

Wednesday, September 26, 2007

The Psychology of Boys

What I Researched and Why:
When I was reading about Tom Sawyer, Huck Finn and all of the mischievious adventures they got themselves into, I immediately thought of the 1986 movie, "Stand By Me." The four boys in the movie leave their town for a night to find "something" (I don't want to spoil it if you haven't seen the movie). They end up getting themselves into a situation that they might not be mature enough to handle, just as Tom and Huck did when they witnessed the act done by Injun Joe in the cemetery. Tom and Huck made a pact never to tell anyone what they saw and at the end of "Stand By Me", the boys end up coming back to town and going their separate ways without discussing what they found, much like the pact between Tom and Huck. These two works were so similar that it made me think about why when we think of "boys" and boy culture we often find them getting into situations like this, and how much boys' curiousity and big imaginations are to blame for their getting into these situations. It made me wonder what really lies in the psychology of boys, especially mischievious ones and to what extent the pranks and situations that boys get themselves into in childhood is "innocent." I also touched upon the differences between what "bad" was considered to be in the nineteenth century and how different those standards might be today.

What I Found:
I searched the internet for anything I could find about the psychology of children, particularly boys. I felt that this website "Boys Don't Cry" was the one that portrayed the characters of Tom Sawyer, Huck Finn and the boys from "Stand By Me" the best. It had a pretty interesting explanation for the supposed "mischieviousness" of boys and what might really lie behind it. I also found the website about the movie "Stand By Me", and that also includes a link on the left side of the website to view a trailer of the movie if you're unfamiliar with it.


My Interpretation:
I felt that the author of the article "Boys Don't Cry" had some really interesting points that could be valid and some that were just reading into the behavior of boys way too much. It also really showed the changing of the times in both parental ways and how seriously violence and "badness" is taken today in contrast to the past. It explained the gender roles that boys must fill by avoiding a title such as, "Mama's Boy" or by the cultural influence for a boy to grow up quickly and take on the position of manhood. Neither Tom nor Huck are "Mama's Boys" and they could be said to be culturally shaped by gender roles; they do mischievious things that most boys do. Joe Harper could be seen as a little bit more of a "Mama's Boy" though, especially when he was the first to decide to leave the island and he said in response to Tom's teasing ways, "Yes, I do want to see my mother- and you would too, if you had one" (p. 87) His response touches upon the next idea that Lawson brings up in his article "Boys Don't Cry" in that "Boys are yearning for adult connection." Neither Huck nor Tom are "Mama's Boys" like Joe, but then again, neither of them have real mothers. Huck is an outcast of society with no one to care for him but a drunken father who in fact doesn't care, and Tom, even though he has Aunt Polly, it's just probably not the same as having a real, biological mom, just like Joe claims in the story. Is it due to parental absence that Tom and Huck are so mischievious? Tom does have parental guidance through Aunt Polly, but is she too strict? These are all problems that are felt by parents, the problems of how children will develop if a parent is too strict or too lenient. Similarly in the movie, "Stand By Me," both Chris and Teddy's fathers are alcoholics, and these two boys are the ones who can be seen as the "bad influences" on Gordie and Vern. Gordie's father and mother are still mourning the past death of their older son, therefore completely forgetting about him, he's a bit mischievious, somewhere in between, and Vern's mother is so oppressive that the boy can't even stay one night out in the woods without getting nervous and upset, kind of like Joe.
The article "Boys Don't Cry" goes on to argue that violence is the result in boys like these, the mischievious boys that are always getting into trouble and just being excused by the phrase "boys will be boys." The violence is the result of depression and vulnerability hidden by a rough exterior. I feel it's a bit extreme to include all boys in this description, but it just goes to show that some behavior just can't be taken so lightly nowadays. On the other end of the spectrum was the section about "Boy Culture" by E. Anthony Rotundo in the back of Twain's book. It shows how violent boys were more a part of the cultural norm in the nineteenth century than they are today. He felt that boys acted the way they did to acheive "independence and character." Often times their games involved pain, but it was just merely "bonds that held boy culture together." If most parents today saw their children inflicting pain on another child, they probably wouldn't just pass it off as a part of boy culture. They would most likely set up an appointment for their child with a child psychologist the next day. The movie "Stand By Me" has a setting in the 1950's and goes to show that just up until recently, most things boys did were considered mischievious, not really bad, like they might seem in today's standards. Boys actions and gender roles haven't changed much, but the perception of bad surely has.

What I Think It Adds To Our Discussion:

Our whole course is devoted to looking at children's books and examining what lies within them to see not only how much they have been changed throughout history, but what lessons they are teaching children and if they are appropriate for children to read. I felt that this post sort of reversed that position and made the reader learn a lesson about parenting and teaching skills that we may one day utilize. The articles that I have presented in this have shown how both parenting skills have changed and how violence in children has taken on a whole new meaning. It presents parents with the problem of "how strict?" or how lenient?" should I be with my child. Will he actually mature one day and should I be taking his "boyish" ways more seriously? Boyhood is a complicated thing to understand, but I feel that mostly every boy will probably go through some part of this life being mischevious and curious, no matter what type of discipline or non-discipline his parents exert. It is only through experience that we learn.




Tuesday, September 25, 2007

What I researched and why: I decided to snatch up this blog entry because I thought it would be relatively easy compared to my other blog on "A Dialogue Between Christ, Youth, and the Devil." As it turns out, it's often the stories you are familiar with that you end up learning the most about as you re-read and analyze what is behind the cover. This definitely ended up being the case as I looked into "The Adventures of Tom Sawyer" several years after my first time reading it as a child. As I looked over the options of short stories, books, and articles from which we could choose to write a blog entry Tom Sawyer's name popped out along with some mental pictures that go hand-in-hand with what this story was and still is for me to this day. Having this in mind I thought it may be interesting to target the illustrations that have accompanied this tale from its beginning till now.

What I found: The first thing I stumbled upon was: http://etext.virginia.edu/railton/tomsawye/tomillhp.html
Here I was able to find various pictures from the very original copy of the book in which Mark Twain himself talks about his appreciation for the artists work. What is compelling to me is that M.T. seemed to have very little if any say in what the illustrations were going to look like, he is quoted saying, "
Poor devil, what a genius he has & how he does murder it with rum. He takes a book of mine, & without suggestion from anybody builds no end of pictures just from his reading of it." This link led me to an website where a drawing of a house supposedly drawn by Tom Sawyer in the book, but probably drawn by Mark Twain himself is shown. This is the link with the picture and bit of information; http://etext.virginia.edu/railton/sc_as_mt/househp.html
I thought this was especially informative because according to the website this house represented something more than just a house. Go figure right? After taking this class I swear there is something behind everything! (: The house that is drawn is apparently a glimpse into the authors history and perhaps a psychological glimpse into what Mark Twain's thoughts about what a man's house represented. Check out the website to gain a little more information on the topic.


My Interpretation and how this relates to what we've discussed in class: There are two parts that I want to discuss included in my search for information on Tom Sawyer. First is the illustrations that went along with the book, these are obviously a very important part of the message that is being portrayed to readers. Through the artists drawings we see certain parts of the book that we may not without them. It's interesting how the characters clothes, tools, and even the landscape can say a lot about the time period which this book was published. Through this we are opened a door into the historical analysis of the book. I'm also curious about the connection between the circular hybrid factor that illustrations may be able to unveil for the reader. This being through clothes, housing, or the general culture, the pictures certainly give us a better perspective on the story as a whole, and therefor would help us to see the impact differing groups of people existing in this civilization had impacted each other.

The connections with the drawing of the house connects with the analysis of children's literature from a psychological stance because it is moving from the characters of the book to the authors perspective of his ideal living situation. As we've been talking about social class through the past few classes this really hit me as thought provoking. How did Mark Twain's social standing affect the book that he wrote?

Monday, September 24, 2007

Mark Twain has come under much scrutiny for his now deemed racist texts. At the time he was writing, the terminologies used to describe African Americans were considered socially acceptable. Today, however, they are considered reprehensible. I feel that when reading The Adventures of Tom Sawyer, we must address the racial issues present there.

Although The Adventures of Tom Sawyer is not a “picture book,” it is often accompanied by illustrations. I find it especially interesting to look at the drawings of Jim, since they are very telling of race relations at the time. Most of these drawings are from Huck Finn, but related to The Adventures of Tom Sawyer.

As the author suggests, many of the pictures of Jim seem to portray him as more of a caricature than as a character. He is also presented this way in the text. His manner of speaking is much more broken than the other characters. This could be contributed to the lack of education at the time. Twain also uses the n-word rather liberally. In his defense, Twain wrote for the common people, and this is how they related to African-Americans. Unfortunately, it would not be believable to the common (white) person that slaves would be articulate.

The Adventures of Tom Sawyer did not have as much blatant racism as The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn did. This is because Jim was a much more prominent character in the sequel. However, the presentations of Jim that we did encounter were still rife with racist undertones. In Chapter 2, the narrator states “although the pump was only a hundred and fifty yards off, Jim never got back with a bucket of water under an hour—and even then somebody generally had to go after him.” This could be viewed as a character flaw of Jim’s, or it could be viewed as a white author calling African Americans lazy, easily distracted, and irresponsible. I think it is worthwhile to address these texts as partners and to discuss them side-by-side. The questions that the reader is left with after reading Tom Sawyer can be answered by Huck Finn. As a reader, I am curious about Jim when he is mentioned in Tom Sawyer, so I appreciate exploring his character more in Huck Finn.

The racism that Twain is usually under attack for involves his portrayal of Jim, but equally important is his portrayal of Injun Joe. Even his name is derogatory. He is seen as a scary and possibly harmful man, and although tales of him are plentiful, we do not have genuine proof that he is dangerous. His race is seen as a mark against him and contributing to his reputation, especially since it is part of his nickname. It is also interesting to notice that Joe’s race is placed before his birth name, that which represents his actual identity. It could be argued, however, that the “Injun” part of his name was used to differentiate between him and Tom’s friend Joe.

I think it is important to address these issues, but I think it is also important to credit Twain for including African-American and Native American characters. He allowed us this opportunity to discuss past and present racism by placing it in a children’s book. He also gave parents the opportunity to explain race relations.

Sunday, September 23, 2007

Tom Sawyer in Song

What I researched and Why: Growing up, I was read bedtime stories by my mother and father, one of which was "Adventures of Huckleberry Finn," the brother story to Mark Twain's "The Adventures of Tom Sawyer." I don't remember much of the story besides various anecdotes but I do remember enjoying it very much. So, when considering which topic/story to blog about I immediately rushed to Tom Sawyer because of my enjoyment of Huck Finn. After reading the first few chapters, my fondness for the rebellious characters of Twain's creation has been rekindled, with what I hope is a more mature understanding and appreciation of the themes than I had as a young child.

What I found:
Searching the internet for relevant Tom Sawyer media proved harder than I would have expected. Most websites were places to read the full text, or an excerpt of the text (the whitewashing section from chapter 2 being particularly popular), or finally a location to buy various versions of the text. What I did stumble across was a music video of the song Tom Sawyer by the classic 80's band Rush, the lyrics of which are obviously inspired by our character Tom Sawyer.

My Interpretation:
My interpretation of this little gem is two fold. Firstly, the lyrics of the song hold what I feel like is a good representation of the basic character of Tom Sawyer (at least as much as I have read) , along with using Tom as a way of describing various characteristic of society. The line "Always hopeful, yet discontent," is an almost perfect portrayal of Tom through the first 6 chapters of the book. One passage which illustrates this most clearly is when he talks about wishing he could die without acknowledging his aunt when she hits him for breaking the sugar bowl, he wallows in self pity wishing that he could teach her a lesson despite the fact that his desired lesson would leave him dead. Another instance where he lives up to the hopeful yet discontent paradigm is when he "shows off" outside of the new girls house, unhappy that she is not visible to him, but hopeful that she is watching from behind closed windows. Rush also uses the character of Tom Sawyer to criticize society, saying "And what you say about his company, Is what you say about society." A clever analogy which I read as, we may enjoy or trust some facet of society, but at the same time we feel like it is getting the better of us somehow (take the television we watch or magazines we read as examples, and then think of the advertising that bombards us in both forms), and we only realize that it has duped us when it laughs in our faces or shows us how wrong it was to be so trusting and easily persuaded. This is something Tom does masterfully in the opening chapters, tricking the other children into whitewashing the fence, and trading them their own things back to get a coveted Bible.

A second form of interpretation is in the existence of the song itself and how Tom, a classic literary character, can jump into mainstream popular culture. This I think is a virtue of Tom's character and the ease with which so many of us can identify with various aspects of his personality, which Mark Twain describes in his preface as a combination of three boys he grew up knowing.

What I think it adds to our discussion:
In class we have discussed the various ways in which a text can be analyzed, we have also talked about whether all texts which are considered children's literature are truly appropriate for them. This song, I think, does a good job of hitting upon both of those issues. It clearly uses the character of Tom Sawyer to make a political sort of commentary, which I think goes hand in hand with a historical analysis, because politics cannot be taken out of context with the history in which they fall. Rush uses Tom to make their own criticism of society and my guess is that Mark Twain did the same thing when writing the book back in his own time. Another aspect of the song is the universality of the lyrics with respect to an audience, not singling out a particular group of people, and therefore making it enjoyable to a wide audience (provided you like the style of music). Tom and his book are similar with respect to the universality of their target audience and how they can be enjoyed and interpreted by all ages. Mark Twain specifically says that he writes not only for the enjoyment of children but also for adults to remember childhood with fondness.

Tuesday, September 18, 2007

A Dialogue Between Christ, Youth and the Devil

What I researched and why: Before this class I had never read or even heard of A Dialogue Between Christ, Youth and the Devil. After reading the piece I was interested, excited to learn more and slightly disturbed all at the same time. The text is not something I would ever give to my own children or to any children that I would teach in a school. Yet, the piece can be found in the 1777 edition of the New England Primer. This book was like a Bible to the Puritans at the time and was the main textbook for private and public schools alike. Even children who were home schooled used this book. It was meant to teach not only what was right and wrong, but things such as the alphabet and simple math as well. Appropriate? I am not so convinced.

What I found: Ok. So, after researching this for about two hours I gave in to the fact that there may not be any other versions or interesting revelations about this text. Everything I looked at related to the New England Primer (1777). This website http://public.gettysburg.edu/~tshannon/his341/nep05pg56.htm
will take you to the page in the 1805 New England Primer where A Dialogue Between Christ, Youth and the Devil is located. There you can look at the entire book and see how it was used to teach many different subjects. The fact that this book was used to teach young children is just terrible in my opinion. I look at this book and see an almost cult-like approach to education. The poems and readings in the book are more like warnings. For example, A Dialogue Between Christ, Youth and the Devil ends with a warning when death comes and says, “Thus end the days of wicked youth, Who won’t obey nor mind he truth…” I think this type of approach to teaching young children would be overwhelming for them and somewhat scary at times.

My interpretation: As I said, my interpretation of this text is that it is warning children about what will happen if they disobey their parents or commit other “wrong doings”. The fact is that children can’t handle this type of text. If a teacher was to give this to a young child, I think they would be terrified. The text is interesting for our class to look at. I think there are many ways that it could be interpreted and many meanings behind each word. Yet, even as I was reading it I thought that it was slightly frightening. The child is literally being told that he is going to die that very day because he insulted Christ. He begs for his life and is denied forgiveness. Were we not brought up to believe that Christ is forgiving and if you ask for forgiveness you shall receive it? This dialogue goes against the things I, and likely many of us, have been told since childhood.

How this relates to our class: For the past few weeks, we have been learning that there are many different ways to analyze every text. A Dialogue Between Christ, Youth and the Devil can be analyzed in many different ways. One way would be psychologically. How does this conversation affect the child? How does his attitude change when he realizes what his fate will be? It is an interesting text with many different possibilities for discussion.