Monday, October 8, 2007

Movie- Where the Wild Things Are

What I researched and Why?
I looked into more modern day interpretations of Maurice Sendak's book Where the Wild Things Are. I remember my father reading this book to me when I was young because he loved the book, but all I remembered about it was that it was a little scary. I eventually outgrew that stage or got used to the story, one or the other, but I wanted to see what other people thought about the book.

What I found?
I found that some people thought that the book was slightly scary, and early readers were concerned about this. Critics early on thought that the book might traumatize children and show them an appreciation for chaos, freedom, and fantasy. These early critics have been overshadowed by the great deal of praise for the book being able to help children deal with "dark emotions". The book was published in 1963 and was the first around that children could really identify with to help them deal with anger.
In the early 1980's Disney had possession of the rights to the book and were considering making an animation film from it. Disney decided to pass for whatever reasons and lost the rights to the story. Currently Warner Bros has possession of these rights and is due to release a live action/ puppet/computer animation movie based on the book. The movie is to open in Oct of 2008 and is being directed by Spike Jonze. The film will be rated PG13 for computer animated violence, language, and adult situations. Movie

My Interpretation
I think it is interesting that the movie will be rated PG13 when the book was designed to help young children deal with anger. The movie is obviously aimed at an older audience. Maybe the audience needs to be able to understand things that the book has already taught them. As I can tell the book currently does not deal with violence, language or adult situations that are over the heads of children under 13. I am curious to see how these situations were included into the film.
Children's interpretation of the story will most likely be altered due to this film. People seem to remember more about a film than they do about a book. This may be do to how much visual stimulus is actually given to you. If someone is given more of how the director sees the story, then they are less likely to use their imagination to create their own ideas about the story.

What this Adds to Class Discussion?
Will the meaning of the story change as a result of this film? Are films a good thing? Do they help children understand a story in a way that will help them, or do they stunt a child's own development of being able to come up with a moral that is age appropriate to them?

Wednesday, October 3, 2007

Native Americans and Racism in The Adventures of Tom Sawyer

What I researched and why: As I read through the critical, secondary text "Why Mark Twain Murdered Injun Joe" I came upon an interesting passage: "We know what was done to Blacks, so we care about Jim; we don't know what was done to Indians, so we care nothing for Joe" (Revard 338). This passage made me question the circumstances and history surrounding the Native Americans and the underlying cause of the racism against them, which could possibly answer why Mark Twain was so hateful towards Injun Joe in "The Adventures of Tom Sawyer". To answer my questions, I turned to the internet to get a brief history of what led to the prejudice against them.

What I found: I searched the web to gain a better understanding of what exactly happened to the Native Americans because I am not as familiar with their history as I am with African American history. I found on essay about the Native Americans that includes an unauthored very concise history (only a couple of sentences) explaining the impact Europeans had on Native American life. Although some of the claims may not be based on fact, the essay provides an interesting insight as to the development of racism against the Native Americans. The author suggests that the treaties made between the American government and the Native Americans was the start of the racism against them. Here is the web address to this site that I discuss in my post: http://www.megaessays.com/viewpaper/24163.html. I also found a site that discusses Twain's ideology concerning American Indians when he wrote this novel, which suggests that Twain viewed Indians as not having a place in American culture and the idea that their bad behavior was caused by bad Indian blood. The web address to this website is http://etext.virginia.edu/railton/projects/rissetto/joe.html.

My interpretation: No where in the history of Native Americans did I find a description of them being murderous or overly criminal, as Mark Twain portrays Injun Joe to be, in fact Native Americans "were overall a peaceful people who enjoyed family, prayer, and creativity" (http://www.indians.org/articles/american-indians.html). The only reason, according to history, that Indians are 'hated' is because Europeans wanted their land, and fought to the death for it. I feel that this history is important in analyzing "The Adventures of Tom Sawyer" because when I read it, I first thought that Injun Joe was only a bad character because he was criminal. I did not realize that the author, Mark Twain, was deceptively inserting his own racist feelings into the text. If Twain's goal was only to depict an criminal character then there is no need to insert the derogatory title 'Injun' in front of his name. Although Mark Twain may have very strong feelings as to why Indians are terrible people, I could not find anything to support the fact that Indians were anymore or anyless criminal than the next person, which completely rejects Twain's "culture of violence" theory he had about Native Americans.

What this adds to our discussion: I feel that this adds to our discussion in that it is important to acknowledge the fact that Mark Twain is wrong in his portrayal of Injun Joe, solely because his basis for Injun Joe's behavior is due to the fact that he is Indian, and not just a bad person. I first read this book in grade school and am concerned that children may also relate Injun Joe's behavior to his ethnic background, as Twain did, thereby reinforcing the unfounded racism against Native Americans.

Retro-Tom

What I Researched/Why: I originally wanted to find some clips of the anime “Adventures of Tom Sawyer” cartoons from the early 1980s that were mentioned in class. I remembered watching these when I was younger and was also curious to see how a Japanese director might have interpreted a classic American story. Unfortunately, I could not find any clips of this cartoon in English (Click Here if you’d like to see one of the non-English versions, they’re pretty funny.)

So, I looked for other cartoon versions of Tom Sawyer, hoping that I could find an interesting interpretation of the story.

What I Found: I found a short (about 6 minutes) “Mel-O-Toons” cartoon titled “Tom Sawyer.”You can Click Here to view it if you can't see it below. It is part of a series of 104 short cartoons released in 1960. The series also featured well known folk-tales, myths and bible stories. such as Cinderella, Noah’s Ark and Robin Hood. I’ve always really liked watching old cartoons, especially the ridiculously politically incorrect ones with those weird narrators, so I was pretty excited about finding this.

Interpretation/What This Adds to Class Discussions: Some of the choices made in shortening the story were very interesting. First, Huck Finn’s character is totally left out in favor of Joe Harper. I think that this must have something to do with the possible moral difficulties of presenting a very poor (yet happy/satisfied) child to young viewers. Maybe showing Huck would somehow threaten the “American dream,” “Pull yourself up by your bootstraps!” mentality that was so prevalent in the 50s-60s. I was also particularly interested in the portrayal of Injun Joe’s character in this cartoon. He has a feather on his head and says things like “I go in peace.” In the book, he was certainly a very evil character, but he was also taken much more seriously.

This cartoon shows the way cultural values and norms can change over time. Clearly what was valued in 1960’s US children’s culture was the portrayal of boyish adventures and doing good deeds. Any moral ambiguity, including the problem of Huck Finn’s character, seemed to be glossed over, even though Twain focused heavily on moral ambiguity in The Adventures of Tom Sawyer. Showing racial stereotypes to children did not seem to be an issue at the time, whereas today this is the kind of thing that would be worried about immensely.

I wonder how a modern adaptation of Tom Sawyer would deal with the character of Injun Joe. I don’t know if anyone has read or seen Shakespeare’s “The Merchant of Venice,” but I was reminded of this play in thinking about what a modern interpretation of Tom Sawyer might be like. “The Merchant of Venice” used to be most frequently performed with an emphasis on its anti-Semitic aspects. Now that this has become culturally unacceptable, many scholars and theaters have re-interpreted the play as actually being sympathetic to its Jewish character, and perform it emphasizing this aspect. I wonder if modern adaptations of Tom Sawyer might take a similar approach, or if they might just leave out Injun Joe’s character altogether, as the cartoon I found did with Huck Finn? Does anyone remember how the movie Tom and Huck dealt with Injun Joe’s character?

Injun Joe: from Racial Fraud to Freud

What I Researched and Why: Carter Revard's disdain for critics and their indifference to the racism of Tom Sawyer's tale is confronted in his article "Why Mark Twain Murdered Injun Joe." Revard writes, "The critics who are alive to every nuance of how Twain, in Huckleberry Finn, kid-gloves the Black and White issues, blatantly ignore his mauling of Red and White questions in Tom Sawyer" (336). Challenged by his statement, I resolved to find out more about Joe and his portrayal, as well as the extrapolated portrayal of all Native Americans. Perusing the internet, I discovered a site that analyzed the classic in regards to this disenfranchised character.

My Findings and Interpretation: The University of Virginia's website, http://xroads.virginia.edu/~HYPER/HNS/Indians/twain3.html, acknowledges the hypocrisy between Twain's writing concerning slaves versus Native Americans. According to the site, Twain sees the Indians as feral and barbaric and insinuates that their savagery will be their downfall as civilization overcomes them. More specifically, http://xroads.virginia.edu/~HYPER/HNS/Indians/joe.html explores Joe's character development within the novel and how it reflects Mark Twain's personal ideology concerning Native Americans.

After struggling to find legitimate discussions online, I agree with Revard in upbraiding critics for overlooking Joe. The few sites I did find barely acknowledged him, despite the nature of his role in the story and its societal impact.
"Twain's Indians" mentions that Twain's vengeful character never elicits the audience's sympathy and his cruel personality can be directly blamed on his bad blood. The web-page does a great job of highlighting scenes and drawing ties to other pieces of the time portraying Indians, including Last of the Mohicans.

One of the popular images in Twain's The Adventures of Tom Sawyer, featured on the "Injun Joe" page, seems to illustrate
Tom's torment following his role as a witness in the murder trial. Twain writes, "His nights were seasons of horror. Joe infested all his dreams, and always with doom in his eye" (118). When I first encountered this sketch, I immediately recalled an unsettling painting by Fuseli, entitled "Nightmare," which can be seen here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Image:Johann_Heinrich_F%C3%BCssli_053.jpg. Although simplified, the content and composition of the pen and ink drawing greatly mimic the 18th century portrait. Joe mirrors a perched incubus, suffocating the supine Tom who is draped identically to the woman. This dream scene invites a whole new Freudian perspective. Tom, like the woman, is pure and good, pale and cherubic, while the monster-like Joe lurks in sinister shadow. In reality Joe is normal in appearance, but the artist makes him as terrifying and savage as Twain makes his personality.

Contributions to Class Discussion: We haven't had the opportunity to really delve into these topics with regards to Tom Sawyer yet, but I'm looking forward to seeing what points will be raised in class on the role of Joe.
It would be interesting to consider how children are affected by the story in these respects, and how their opinions of Native Americans are shaped thanks to Joe's character and the illustrations which accompany it. The Adventures of Tom Sawyer may be regarded as a beloved albeit juvenile tale, but it also presents weighty issues and deeper meanings. Analysis of the book's portrayal of race is a crucial endeavor well-suited for political and historical theories; additionally, the nightmare scene invites us to take a more unconventional, psychological approach as well. Instead of being shunned by men and women as Twain feared, the book is the perfect medium for us to apply academic discussions.

Monday, October 1, 2007

Tom Sawyer Island

What I researched and Why:
One of the earlier posts talked about the transformation of Tom Sawyer Island in Disneyland into a Pirates of the Caribbean attraction. I thought the idea of a whole island which brings to life something that existed in a work of literature was interesting, so I decided to find out more.

What I found:
http://www.allearsnet.com/tp/mk/mk_tsi.htm
This site tells about Tom Sawyer Island, which other sites confirms is still Tom Sawyer Island, but with an area devoted to Pirates. Considering Tam, Huck, and Joe's adventures while they had 'drowned,' this does not seem altogether inappropriate. They have an 'Injun Joe' Cave, a raft that ferries tourists to the island, paths and hills, and an Ice Cream shop called 'Aunt Polly's that is designed to look like a period house. there are some other things not mentioned in the book, but do follow its character. There is a Mill and a Fort; perhaps these would be the product of the boys' imaginations.
After researching this I remembered another, similar piece of information. Orlando Studios is in the process of creating a Harry Potter theme park in Florida complete with castle, magical village, and train. The images on their website seem to promise a big visual payout on the investment.
http://www.universalorlando.com/harrypotter/


My Interpretation:
I think it is very interesting that in the modern era we seek to live our fictions. It is not enough for us to simply read Tom Sawyer or Harry Potter or to simply watch Pirates of the Caribbean. We want to touch and taste and smell all of it. Why is that? I'm not sure I know the answer, but here are a few possibilities. Maybe we are spoiled by media systems that have grown beyond their creators so that our attention deficit cannot handle having only one ore two senses stimulated at a time. Maybe Disney and Orlando build them, and so we come. In other words, maybe the demand is driven by the production. Or maybe the technology and the economy have simply grown far enough for us to be able to do this and we would have in every era before, but didn't have the means. Or we could take a really optimistic view and say that we are simply more involved with the literature in the modern era than common people have ever been, and therefore want more and more of it, and in varying avenues of absorption.

What it adds to our discussion:
I think the question raised in my interpretation is a good one for discussion. I brought the topic forward and even I don't know what I think of it. Has our society changed so much? Has our media changed so much? What effect might such 'amusement parks' have on future generations and particularly on children's literature? And are these parks a way of subverting the subversive side of children's literature? I suppose I have more questions than answers.

Little Women: girl-book, boy-book, or neither?

My research and findings:
I was very interested in the nineteenth-century idea of the “girl-book” and “boy-book.” The first thing that I looked at (briefly) was the book The Story of a Bad Boy by Thomas Bailey Aldrich (the boy-book of the day). Google has actually digitized the entire book, so I was able to read a little and examine the images. (The book that is displayed is the original version from 1870, and I was immediately struck by the illustrations. You’ll know what I’m talking about when you look at them). I found Aldrich’s writing style to be quite humorous. Here’s a little snippet from the first chapter:
"Lest the title should mislead the reader, I hasten to assure him here that I have no dark confessions to make. I call my story the story of a bad boy, partly to distinguish myself from those faultless young gentlemen who generally figure in narratives of this kind, and partly because I really was not a cherub. "
While I was reading the first few pages of The Story of a Bad Boy, I found myself wondering how Little Women came to be considered the “girl-book” when the main character (Jo) is a such a tomboy. I found an article from the New England Quarterly by John W. Crowley which discusses this exact conundrum.

My Interpretation:
Crowley discusses the idea of the boy-book and the manner in which it was introduced to the reading public, stressing the point that it “depicts a child’s world that is antagonistic to the world of adults”. He goes on to examine the world of Alcott’s Little Women and its qualification as a girl-book. He claims that it cannot be considered a girl-book because
"Aldrich, Mark Twain, Howells, and other writers of the boy-book imagine a boy-world distinct from both the adult spheres (or at least from the woman’s sphere) [while] Alcott shows the girl-world to by circumscribed by the woman’s sphere and governed by its civilizing codes. "
In my opinion, the way that the woman’s world informs that of the girl could be the main difference between the “boy-book” and the “girl-book”; however, I don’t disagree with everything that Crowley discusses in this essay. The majority of his essay is spent discussing Jo’s character and her boyishness and aggressive nature. While Jo is still a young, nurturing woman with a tendency to be dramatic and emotional, she does not fret over her appearance (cutting her hair for money to support her family) and works very hard to be a writer. She wishes that she and her sisters were boys so that “’then there wouldn’t be any bother!’” and “submits herself to a reforming self-discipline: ‘I’ll try to be what he loves to call me, a little woman, and not be rough and wild’”. This reformation and acceptance of the role which one must play in the adult world is another aspect of the boy-book which can be applied to Little Women, and therefore increases its ambiguity as a girl-book.

What I think it adds to our class discussion:
In children’s literature today, the line between girl-book/boy-book has become increasingly blurred. Sure, there are some: The Babysitters’ Club, Sweet Valley High, Hardy Boys. But the most recent and popular books like Harry Potter and Lemony Snicket’s A Series of Unfortunate Events contain characters which cross the traditional gender boundaries. I feel that in examining books of other time periods, it is helpful to view them through a more critical lens than that to which we might be accustomed. Little Women may be called a girl-book because its main characters are all female; however, we must examine it closely to determine whether the distinction between boy-book and girl-book has always been as clear as we have assumed.

Thursday, September 27, 2007

What I researched and why: In looking over the course materials, I noticed that, for me, they fell into two categories. There were stories that I wasn't familiar with because they came far before my time (Little King Pippin; A Dialogue Between Christ, Youth, and the Devil) and there were children's books that I, or members of my immediate family, was raised reading (Where the Wild Things Are; 17 Things I'm Not Allowed to Do). However, The Adventures of Tom Sawyer fell squarely in the middle of these two categories. As a child, I was familiar with the story (do we all remember Wishbone?) but the book wasn't something that I was actually exposed to until high school, when I read it in an English course. It's on the boundary between the two categories: something I can examine as an integral part of my childhood, and something I can examine as a part of history. The fact that I never really read the book but was familiar with the story and its characters intrigued me, particularly as American society today is accused of being "illiterate." Even if books are being steadily devalued, how much has their influence permeated into the new, technological culture that seems to be rising?

What I Found: I began by searching Digg, a popular social networking and news site. I found an interesting article about how the phrase "Tom Sawyer" is used in reference to websites who, essentially, get their users to do their dirty work for them (a la Aunt Polly's fence). However, a more relevant site talks about how Disney replaced their Tom Sawyer attraction with one dedicated to Pirates of the Caribbean. On the opposite side of the fence, I found several instances of Tom Sawyer in children's media in the last few years, including a children's cartoon and, of course, our beloved Jonathan Taylor Thomas.

My Interpretation: It seems to me that in all the to-do about literature's disappearance in the western world over the last few decades ignores one of the largest demographics affected by its loss: children. As a child, I was raised on Where the Wild Things Are, Winnie the Pooh, the Nancy Drew series, and many more terrific books geared toward young readers. However, with the exception of Harry Potter, the amount of reading children seem to be doing has been dropping dramatically. I've seen this in my own younger brothers; my 11-year-old brother spends approximately 8 hours a day in front of the television. A quote in an article on a different site about Disney's actions sums this transition up quite succinctly: "
That's very valuable real estate [in the theme park], and if you ask a hundred kids who Jack Sparrow and Tom Sawyer are, what do you think they're going to say?"

The question I propose is whether it does more harm than good to adapt books to other forms of media rather than in their original form. As a child, one of the most aspects of reading a book was the fact that visually, you were forced to imagine the scene, rather than having it presented to you preformed. I feel that, particularly in Tom Sawyer, this removes a valuable part of the book; in addition, it takes away a lot of the subtleties of Tom's thinking process as well, which children grasp better than we may anticipate.

What I Think it Adds to Our Discussion: We've talked a lot about the question of what's appropriate to present to children: which version of Little Red Riding Hood is the least destructive? However, in a culture where literature and media are becoming integrated in the way I've presented, the question must be taken a step further: Is it enough to present an interpretation of the work, or do we need to stress presentation of the original? Here's an example of an issue to take into consideration: Tom Sawyer deals with a lot of very real, serious issues: sickness, death, and religion are just a few examples. Can we really get these points across to children in a 1.5 hour, animated, anthropomorphic TV special? Does presenting classic literature in this way undermine the value of the work itself? However, have we come too far to go back and encourage our children to read without alienating them from their culture?