Monday, September 24, 2007

Mark Twain has come under much scrutiny for his now deemed racist texts. At the time he was writing, the terminologies used to describe African Americans were considered socially acceptable. Today, however, they are considered reprehensible. I feel that when reading The Adventures of Tom Sawyer, we must address the racial issues present there.

Although The Adventures of Tom Sawyer is not a “picture book,” it is often accompanied by illustrations. I find it especially interesting to look at the drawings of Jim, since they are very telling of race relations at the time. Most of these drawings are from Huck Finn, but related to The Adventures of Tom Sawyer.

As the author suggests, many of the pictures of Jim seem to portray him as more of a caricature than as a character. He is also presented this way in the text. His manner of speaking is much more broken than the other characters. This could be contributed to the lack of education at the time. Twain also uses the n-word rather liberally. In his defense, Twain wrote for the common people, and this is how they related to African-Americans. Unfortunately, it would not be believable to the common (white) person that slaves would be articulate.

The Adventures of Tom Sawyer did not have as much blatant racism as The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn did. This is because Jim was a much more prominent character in the sequel. However, the presentations of Jim that we did encounter were still rife with racist undertones. In Chapter 2, the narrator states “although the pump was only a hundred and fifty yards off, Jim never got back with a bucket of water under an hour—and even then somebody generally had to go after him.” This could be viewed as a character flaw of Jim’s, or it could be viewed as a white author calling African Americans lazy, easily distracted, and irresponsible. I think it is worthwhile to address these texts as partners and to discuss them side-by-side. The questions that the reader is left with after reading Tom Sawyer can be answered by Huck Finn. As a reader, I am curious about Jim when he is mentioned in Tom Sawyer, so I appreciate exploring his character more in Huck Finn.

The racism that Twain is usually under attack for involves his portrayal of Jim, but equally important is his portrayal of Injun Joe. Even his name is derogatory. He is seen as a scary and possibly harmful man, and although tales of him are plentiful, we do not have genuine proof that he is dangerous. His race is seen as a mark against him and contributing to his reputation, especially since it is part of his nickname. It is also interesting to notice that Joe’s race is placed before his birth name, that which represents his actual identity. It could be argued, however, that the “Injun” part of his name was used to differentiate between him and Tom’s friend Joe.

I think it is important to address these issues, but I think it is also important to credit Twain for including African-American and Native American characters. He allowed us this opportunity to discuss past and present racism by placing it in a children’s book. He also gave parents the opportunity to explain race relations.

3 comments:

Daniel Wilkinson said...

I agree with your articulation of the importance of bringing the race relation questions up early. And I feel like modern society has shunned the Twain's writings unfairly. Without going into too much detail, I think that the parlance of the time is an important historical aspect of the stories and is instructive. This being said, I did not think that the anecdote of Jim taking a long time at the water pump was meant to point out any sort of laziness but rather to show that people had fun at the water pump, and thats why Tom wanted to trade jobs with Jim.

Katy K said...

I wanted to amend my post by saying that Injun Joe did, in fact, commit a crime--murder! How could I forget that?! My apologies.

Evan B said...

I recently re-read The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn, and I found it to be extremely anti-racist. Despite the dialect Twain uses (which, especially in Huckleberry Finn, he uses variations of for all of the characters,) and the frequent use of the n-word (much more than in TS,) Jim comes across as a man well deserving of respect by the end of the book. I think it is unfair to say that TS is a racist book on these grounds alone. I think we COULD possibly hold the book accountable for not dealing with the subject of racism towards blacks much at all, however. (at least from what I've read so far)

I'm also really looking forward to talking about Injun Joe's character, and what Twain may have been thinking there. So far, his relating IJ's crime and personality to his race seems out of place to me, because so much of the book deals with the messes that ensue when people jump to conclusions and make assumptions. (ex. The boys being dead, almost convicting the wrong man)